- Contractual relations
- Key European Council conclusions
- Key EU strategy documents
- EU monitoring reports
- Pre-accession funds
- Economic recovery
- Bulgaria's accession to the Schengen area
- Judiciary, corruption and crime
- Environment
- Rural development
This section offers more than 150 key texts and background documents on the Bulgarian EU accession process. The first section, contractual relations, includes all major pre-accession agreements between the EU and Bulgaria, from the 1993 Association Agreement (called the Europe Agreement at the time) to the Accession Treaty itself. Key European Council conclusions includes those Council conclusions where decisions crucial for Bulgaria's accession were taken.
Major strategy papers developed by DG Enlargement with regard to Bulgaria's run-up to accession are listed in key EU strategy documents related specifically to Bulgaria. The section EU monitoring reports lists all formal monitoring documents, from the 1997 opinion (or avis) to the latest post-accession reports on progress under the "co-operation and verification mechanism" (set up by the European Commission to monitor and assist required reforms in the areas of judiciary, corruption and organised crime). It is followed by a section on pre-accession funds, which gives more details on EU funding for Bulgaria, from regulations on the pre-accession instruments (Phare, ISPA and SAPARD) to respective financial reports and critical assessments by the European Court of Auditors and other institutions.
The last five sub-sections provide a selection of documents on five particular issues related to Bulgaria's accession process: Bulgaria's spectacular economic recovery after the crisis of 1997, judiciary, corruption and crime, and Bulgaria's accession to the Schengen area as well as two examples of areas where Bulgaria's EU accession process has triggered enormous institutional and policy change: environment and rural development.
Contractual relations
The 1993 Europe Agreement is an association agreement that corresponds roughly to the current Stabilisation and Association Agreements for the Western Balkans. Looking at the Accession Partnerships from different periods gives a good overview of how the EU's reform priorities have changed over time.
- Accession Treaty (2005)
- EC, Report on the Results of the Negotiations on the Accession of Bulgaria and Romania to the European Union (February 2005)
- Accession Partnership 2003
- Accession Partnership 2001
- Accession Partnership 1999
- Additional Protocol to the Europe Agreement (on trade in textile products) (1997)
- Europe Agreement (signed 1993, entered into force 1995)
Key European Council conclusions
Two European Council decisions in particular were of crucial importance for Bulgaria: the Luxembourg European Council 1997, which launched the accession process for the ten East European former communist countries, including Bulgaria (although Bulgaria had just suffered a devastating economic and political crisis). The second one is the Helsinki European Council 1999, which opened accession negotiations with Bulgaria, along with Latvia, Lithuania, Malta and Slovakia.
- Brussels European Council conclusions, confirming the conclusion of accession negotiations with Bulgaria (17 December 2004 )
- Helsinki European Council conclusions, opens accession negotiations with Bulgaria, along with Latvia, Lithuania, Malta, Romania and Slovakia (10-11 December 1999)
- Luxembourg European Council conclusions, launching the accession process with 10 CEE countries, including Bulgaria; effectively granting candidate status (12-13 December 1997)
Key EU strategy documents
The strategy documents on the enlargement process produced by the European Commission relevant for Bulgaria. While most cover all accession countries of the 5th enlargement round, a few Commission strategy documents are related specifically to Bulgaria (and Romania), after it had become clear that these two countries would not join the EU alongside the other accession countries in 2004.
- EC, Enlargement Strategy Paper 2004 (6 October 2004)
- EC, A financial package for the accession negotiations with Bulgaria and Romania (10 February 2004)
- EC, Enlargement Strategy Paper 2003 (5 November 2003)
- EC, Roadmap for Bulgaria and Romania (13 November 2002)
- EC, Enlargement Strategy Paper 2003 (5 November 2003)
- EC, Enlargement Strategy Paper 2002 (9 October 2002)
- EC, Enlargement Strategy Paper 2001
- EC, Enlargement Strategy Paper 2000
- EC, Composite paper on the regular reports 1999 (incl. Annex 1)
- EC, Composite paper on the regular reports 1999 – Annex 2
- EC, Composite paper on the regular reports 1999 – Annex 3
- EC, Composite paper on the regular reports 1999 – Annex 4
- EC, Composite paper on the regular reports 1999 – Annex 5
- EC, Composite paper on the regular reports 1998
EU monitoring reports
Here you find all official reports prepared by DG Enlargement on Bulgaria, including the "opinion" on Bulgaria's application in 1997, all regular reports, the monitoring reports after negotiations were closed, and the reports prepared under the co-operation and verification mechanism after accession.
- EC, Report from Commission on Progress in Bulgaria under the Co-operation and Verification Mechanism (08 February 2012)
- EC, Report from Commission on Progress in Bulgaria under the Co-operation and Verification Mechanism (Technical Update) (20 July 2011)
- EC, Report from Commission on Progress in Bulgaria under the Co-operation and Verification Mechanism (20 July 2011)
- EC, Report from Commission on Progress in Bulgaria under the Co-operation and Verification Mechanism (18 February 2011)
- EC, Report from Commission on Progress in Bulgaria under the Co-operation and Verification Mechanism (Technical Update) (20 July 2010)
- EC, Report from Commission on Progress in Bulgaria under the Co-operation and Verification Mechanism (20 July 2010)
- EC, Report from Commission on Progress in Bulgaria under the Co-operation and Verification Mechanism (Technical Update) (22 July 2009)
- EC, Report from Commission on Progress in Bulgaria under the Co-operation and Verification Mechanism (22 July 2009)
- EC, Report from the Commission on Progress in Bulgaria under the Co-operation and Verification Mechanism (23 July 2008)
- EC, Supporting Document on Progress in Bulgaria under the Co-operation and Verification Mechanism: Technical Update (23 July 2008)
- EC, Report from the Commission on the Management of EU-funds in Bulgaria (23 July 2008)
- EC, Interim Report from the Commission on Progress in Bulgaria under the Co-operation and Verification Mechanism (14 February 2008)
- EC, Report on Bulgaria's progress on accompanying measures following Accession (27 June 2007)
- EC,2006 Comprehensive monitoring report on the state of preparedness for EU membership of Bulgaria and Romania (26 September 2006)
- EC, Bulgaria – 2006 Monitoring Report (16 May 2006)
- EC, Bulgaria – 2005 Comprehensive Monitoring Report (25 October 2005)
- EC, Regular Report Bulgaria 2004
- EC, Regular Report Bulgaria 2003
- EC, Regular Report Bulgaria 2002
- EC, Regular Report Bulgaria 2001
- EC, Regular Report Bulgaria 2000
- EC, Regular Report Bulgaria 1999
- EC, Regular Report Bulgaria 1998
- EC, Commission Opinion on Bulgaria's Application for Membership of the European Union (15 July 1997)
An overview of the Co-operation and Verification Mechanism can be found here:
- Dimitar Markov, The Cooperation and Verification Mechanism Three Years Later: What Has Been Done and What Is Yet to Come? Friedrich Ebert Stiftung, January 2010
Pre-accession funds
This section provides additional reports and web links on Bulgaria and EU pre-accession funds. A very good portal, with regularly updated financial information is the EU funds management website at the Bulgarian Ministry of Finance. Further below you will find reports of the European Court of Auditors, evaluation reports commissioned by the EC and European regulations on the pre-accession funds. The first Bulgarian National Development Plan is another interesting document, the first to include a comprehensive plan on how to spend EU aid over a seven year programme.
- Bulgarian Ministry of Finance, EU funds management website
- Official ISPA programme website of the European Commission
- Bulgarian Ministry of Finance, ISPA implementation sheet (30 November 2008)
- Bulgarian Ministry of Finance, ISPA implementation sheet (31 December 2006)
- European Court of Auditors, Special Report No 4/2006 concerning Phare investment projects in Bulgaria and Romania, together with the replies of the Commission (2006)
- European Court of Auditors, Special Report No 5/2004 concerning Phare support to prepare Candidate Countries for managing the Structural Funds, together with the Commission's replies (2004)
- Ecotec, Interim Evaluation of the European Union Pre-Accession Instrument Phare. Bulgaria, Regional Development (September 2004)
- Ecotec, Interim Evaluation of the European Union Pre-Accession Instrument Phare. Bulgaria, various sectors, revised draft (December 2003)
- European Court of Auditors, Special Report No 5/2003 concerning PHARE and ISPA funding of environmental projects in the candidate countries together with the Commission's replies; and Special Report No 6/2003 concerning twinning as the main instrument to support institution-building in candidate countries together with the Commission's replies (2003)
- National Development Plan 2000-2006 (updated 2003)
- EC, The Enlargement Process and the three pre-accession instruments: Phare, ISPA, Sapard (February 2002)
- Council Regulation 1266/1999 (pre-accession instruments)
- Council Regulation 1267/1999 ("ISPA regulation")
- Council Regulation 3966/1989 ("Phare regulation")
For documents on the Sapard programme see the section on Rural Development.
Economic recovery
This section provides a selection of texts and information about Bulgaria's stunning economic transformation, from World Bank reports to an online database of most recent macroeconomic indicators, to texts of leading Bulgarian economists.
- World Bank, Bulgaria: Country Partnership Strategy 2011 - 2013 (April 2011)
- Georgi Angelov, The Eurozone Enlargement - Viewpoint from Bulgaria, European Policy Initiative (Open Society Institute-Sofia), Policy Brief (March 2011)
- EC, DG Regional Policy, Bulgaria: Country Report on Achievements on Cohesion Policy (November 2010)
- World Bank, Bulgaria: Public Finance Policy Review. Leveraging EU Funds for Productivity and Growth (February 2006)
- Boyko Nikolov, Nikolay Markov, Nasko Dochev and Ruman Dobrinsky, "Understanding Reform Success and Failure: A Country Study for Bulgaria", Centre for Economic and Strategic Research (February 2005)
- Maria Laura Lanzeni, "Bulgaria in the EU: Challenges and opportunities", presentation at conference "60 days before EU: what to expect, what to do?" in Sofia (18 October 2006)
- World Bank, Bulgaria: The Road to Successful EU Integration – The Policy Agenda, Country Economic Memorandum (November 2005)
- World Bank, Bulgaria: The Dual Challenge of Transition and Accession (February 2001)
- Ilian Mihov, The Economic Transition in Bulgaria 1989-1999, INSEAD (September 1999)
- Roumen Avramov, "The Rebirth of the Market in Bulgaria – 'Economic Memory' and Transition", Centre for Liberal Strategies (1995)
Judiciary, corruption and crime
Bulgaria has a particularly bad reputation with regard to corruption and organised crime. Except for descriptions of individual cases and alarmist newspaper articles, however, there are not many analytical reports on these topics. Here you will find materials on the judiciary and the fight against organised crime, including a few selected news articles. Some of the reports are older, as there are not many recent studies available.
- Transparency International Bulgaria: National Integrity System Assessment, Country Report 2011 (2011)
- Center for the Study of Democracy, Anti-corruption in Public Procurement: Balancing the policies (case study Bulgaria and Norway) (2011)
- Center for the Study of Democracy, Public Trust in the Criminal Justice System – an Instrument for Penal Policy Assessment (Policy Brief) (May 2011)
- Center for the Study of Democracy, Crime Trends in Bulgaria 2000 – 2010 (2011)
- Center for the Study of Democracy, Examining the Links between Organised Crime and Corruption (2010)
- Center for the Study of Democracy, Crime without Punishement: Countering Corruption and Organized Crime in Bulgaria (2009)
- Center for the Study of Democracy, Criminal Justice and Law Enforcement along Bulgaria's Borders: The Impact of EU Accession, Brief (April 2008)
- Center for the Study of Democracy, Effective Policies Targeting the Corruption – Organised Crime Nexus in Bulgaria: Closing Down Duty-Free Outlets, Brief (December 2007)
- Center for the Study of Democracy, Reinforcing Criminal Justice in Border Districts, Report (2007)
- Centre for Liberal Strategies (CLS), The Judiciary: Independent and Accountable. Indicators on the Efficiency of the Bulgarian Judicial System (2007)
- EC, Commission Decision establishing a mechanism for cooperation and verification of progress in Bulgaria to address specific benchmarks in the areas of judicial reform and the fight against corruption and organised crime (13 December 2006)
- Ilija Trojanow, "Bulgaria: the mafia's dance to Europe", Open Democracy (16 August 2006)
- EU Observer, "Bulgaria courts EU with summer clampdown on sleaze" (22 July 2006)
- Susette Schuster "4th Peer Review", on judicial reform (February 2006)
- Klaus Jansen, "Peer Review: Justice and Home Affairs, focus area fight against organised crime" (February 2006)
- Center for the Study of Democracy, Judicial Reform: The Prosecution Office and Investigation Authorities in the Context of EU Membership, report (2005)
- Council of Europe – European Commission for the Efficiency of Justice (CEPEJ), European Judicial Systems 2006 (2004 data)
- Council of Europe – European Commission for the Efficiency of Justice (CEPEJ), European Judicial Systems 2002. Facts and figures on the basis of a survey conducted in 40 Council of Europe Member States (2002)
- Ilija Trojanow, "Bulgaria's red mafia on Europe's trail", Open Democracy (19 January 2006)
- Center for the Study of Democracy (CSD), Crime Trends in Bulgaria: Police Statistics and Victimization Surveys (2005)
- Rashko Dorosiev, "Bulgarians bored by anti-corruption campaigns", IWPR (11 February 2005)
- Open Society Institute, Corruption and Anti-Corruption Policy in Bulgaria, Monitoring the EU Accession Process EUMAP (2002)
- Open Society Institute, Monitoring the EU Accession Process: Corruption and Anti-Corruption Policy, CEE overview, EUMAP (2002)
- Open Society Institute, Judicial Capacity in Bulgaria, Monitoring the EU Accession Process EUMAP (2002)
- Open Society Institute, Monitoring the EU Accession Process: Judicial Capacity, CEE overview, EUMAP (2002)
- Open Society Institute, Judicial Independence in Bulgaria, Monitoring the EU Accession Process EUMAP (2001)
- Open Society Institute, Judicial Independence in the EU Accession Process, CEE overview, Monitoring the EU Accession Process EUMAP (2001)
With the Centre for the Study of Democracy (CSD), Bulgaria boasts one of Europe's most sophisticated corruption research institutes. Its costly empirical studies, based on a methodology developed by the centre over nearly a decade, belong to the best of their kind in Europe. Below you will find all available annual reports. For those who want only an overview, a CSD 13-pager on Corruption Trends and Anti-Corruption in Bulgaria 1998 – 2006 makes perfect reading.
- Anti-Corruption Reforms in Bulgaria. Key Results and Risks (2007)
- On the Eve of EU Accession: Anti-corruption Reforms in Bulgaria (2006)
- Anticorruption Reforms in Bulgaria (2004)
- Corruption Assessment Report (2003)
- Corruption Assessment Report (2002)
- Corruption Assessment Report (2001) (to be downloaded by chapter)
- Corruption Assessment Report (2000)
- Corruption Assessment Report (1999)
Bulgaria's accession to the Schengen area
Although Bulgaria meets the Schengen technical criteria, Bulgaria has still not joined the Schengen area due to resistance from some member states, in particular the Netherlands who demands more reforms in the areas of judiciary and the fighta against corruption. For more information on this process and the related debate see our background section Bulgaria's efforts to join the Schengen area. The most important related key documents you find here:
Documents by EU institutions:
- Protocol Concerning the Conditions and Arrangements for Admission of the Republic of Bulgaria and Romania to the EU, June 2005
- EC, Decision on establishing a mechanism for cooperation and verification of progress in Bulgaria to address specific benchmarks in the areas of judicial reform and the fight against corruption and organised crime (Cooperation and Verification Mechanism), December 2006
- Council of the European Union, Draft Council Decision of the Full Application of the Provisions of the Schengen Aquis in the Republic of Bulgaria and Romania, 29 September 2010
- Council of the European Union, Council conclusions on completion of the process of evaluation of the state of preparedness of Bulgaria to implement all provisions of the Schengen acquis, 9 June 2011 (made public 24 June 2011)
- Press release on Council conclusions, 3096th Council meeting, Justice and Home Affairs Luxembourg, 9/10 June 2011
Documents by the Bulgarian government:
- Declaration for Readiness (Ministerial Council Decision), August 2007 (available in Bulgarian only)
- Common Declaration by Romania and Bulgaria on the Accession to the Schengen Area, January 2008
- Power Point Presentation, Ministry of Interior of Republic of Bulgaria, Progress of Bulgaria in the preparation for joining the Schengen area: January 2007 - July 2009 and July 2009 - January 2011, January 2011
Other Reports:
- Council of Europe, Office of the Commissioner for Human Rights, Assessment of the Progress Made in Implementing the Recommendations of the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights 2001 - 2005, March 2006
- Open Society Institute, State of Preparedness of the Republic of Bulgaria for joining the Schengen Zone, September 2007
- Council of Europe, Office of the Commissioner for Human Rights, Human Rights of Minorities and of Children in Institutions, February 2010
- Open Society Institute, Progress Report of Bulgaria towards Accession to the Schengen Area as of 31st January 2011, 2011
- Open Society Institute, Mid-term Report on the Progress of Bulgaria towards accession to the Schengen Area, 2012
Selected newspaper articles:
- Novinite.com (English-language news portal), Bulgaria Invests EUR 240 M to Meet Schengen Requirements, 1 February 2008
- European Parliament News, Bulgaria, Romania ready to join Schengen area, says Parliament, 9 June 2011
- EU Business (news portal), Dutch to decide on Bulgaria, Romania Schengen bids by 2012, 9 June 2011
- 24 hours Daily Newspaper, Влизането в Шенген е национален приоритет, каза Цветанов (Tsvetanov said: Getting in to Schengen is a national priority), 18 September 2011
- Novinite.com, Netherlands, Finland 'in Isolation' for Vetoing Bulgaria's Schengen Bid - Interior Min, 22 September 2011
- Pop Valentina, "Bulgaria and Romania’s Schengen bid vetoed", EUobserver, 22 September 2011
- Castle Stephen, "Europe Denies 2 Nations Entry to Travel Zone", New York Times, 22 September 2011
- HS International Edition, "Finland eases position on Bulgarian and Romanian membership in Schengen. Finland would accept both countries under certain conditions", 16 November 2011
- Novinite.com, "Dutch Say Firm No on Bulgaria's Gradual Schengen Entry", 13 December 2011
- Nielsen Nikolaj, "Romania and Bulgaria lagging behind on reforms", EU Observer, 8 February 2012
- Toby Vogel, "Bulgaria and Romania edge towards Schengen", European Voice, 9 February 2012
- EU Business, "Netherlands douses Romania, Bulgaria Schengen hopes", 1 March 2012
- Turkish Weekly, "Bulgarian PM Blames Schengen Failure on Dutch Far Rights", 3 March 2012
Key documents: Environment
- Bulgarian Ministry of Environment and Water Website
- EC, DG Environment website
- Website for Bulgarian Operational Programme Environment 2007-2013
- Bulgarian Ministry of Environment and Water, Operational Programme Environment 2007-2013 ( 2007)
- Ministry of Finance of Bulgaria, Financial Implementation of ISPA, National Funds Directorate ( 30 November 2006)
- EC, Annual Report of the Instrument for Structural Policy for Pre-Accession (ISPA)(2005)
- EC, Annual Report of the Instrument for Structural Policy for Pre-Accession (ISPA)(2004)
- EC, Annual Report of the Instrument for Structural Policy for Pre-Accession (ISPA) (2004 – Annex)
- EC, Annual Report of the Instrument for Structural Policy for Pre-Accession (ISPA), last report with data on all applicant countries (2003)
- EC, Main administrative structures required for implementing the acquis, Informal Working Document (May 2000, update 7 June 2004)
- ECOTEC, The benefits of compliance with the environmental acquis for the candidate countries (July 2001).
- Bulgarian Ministry of Environment and Water, National Strategy – Environment Sector (October 2000)
- EC, Handbook for Implementation of EU Environmental Legislation, Draft (November 1999)
- OECD, Environmental Performance Reviews – Bulgaria, OECD, conclusions and recommendations (1996)
Key documents: Rural Development
- Website of the Bulgarian Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry
- Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry, Ongoing and Mid-Term Evaluation of the RDP 2007-2013, covered period 2008 (December 2010)
- Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry, Ongoing and Mid-Term Evaluation of the RDP 2007-2013, covered period 2007-2009 (December 2010)
- Republic of Bulgaria, National Strategy Plan for Rural Development 2007-2013 (January 2007)
- Republic of Bulgaria, National Strategy Plan for Rural Development 2007-2013 – Annexes
- Republic of Bulgaria, Rural Development Programme 2007-2013 (December 2007)
- Republic of Bulgaria, Rural Development Programme 2007-2013 – Annexes
- SAPARD financial monitoring, spreadsheet (31 May 2007)
- Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry, Annual Report 2007
- Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry, Annual Report 2007 – Annexes
- Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry, Annual Report 2005
- Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry, Annual Report 2004
- European Court of Auditors, Special Report No 2/2004 concerning pre-accession aid: Has Sapard been well-managed? Together with the Commission's replies (2004)
- EMS, Phare Agriculture Sector review. Interim Evaluation of Phare Support Allocated in 1999-2002 and Implemented until November 2003 (April 2004)
- UNDP, Bulgaria National Human Development Report 2003 – Rural Regions: Overcoming Development Disparities, Sofia 2004, p. 45
- Alan Wilkinson, The Sapard instrument on the eve of accession, conference paper (March 2004)
- Republic of Bulgaria, National Agricultural and Rural Development Plan 2000-2006 (NARDP)
- EC, Directorate General for Agriculture, Agricultural Situation in the Candidate Countries. Country Report on Bulgaria (July 2002)
- Institutional scheme of management of the Sapard programme
- EC, Commission Regulation, laying down financial rules for the application of Council Regulation (EC) No 1268/1999 on Community support for pre-accession measures for agriculture and rural development in the applicant countries of central and eastern Europe in the pre-accession period (7 June 2000)
- Council Regulation 1268/1999 ("Sapard regulation")
| Weitersagen: | Was bedeutet das? |
